Wednesday, 8 April 2015

International News Round Up


Unfortunately, due to assignment deadlines, revision and work I haven’t had a lot of time to assign to the blog this last week. However, I’m so thankful for all my new followers that I feel the need to post! So here is a brief round up of what’s been happening outside the UK this last week and how they’re gendered.


Garissa Attack

Last Friday militants from the Somalian Islamist militant group Al-Shabab attacked Garissa University in Kenya. 148 young women and men were murdered and others held hostage and injured. My frustration with the media is two fold on this front. Firstly, the death toll has not been disaggregated by gender and it always should be. Especially given the likelihood that the attack had something to do with western education, particularly for girls as well as religious conflict. Secondly, in January 2014, 12 French lives were taken in a similar attack and the international community exploded. The attack was all over social media with the hashtag #JeSuisCharlie, there were countless opinion pieces and even an international leaders summit to mourn the death and make a stand for freedom of speech. Where is our JeSuisGarissa? Our international mourning for the 148 young people killed last week? Western lives should not matter more than African lives. This may not be a gendered analysis but it is important to consider from a postcolonial feminist perspective. My thoughts are with all the families who lost lives in the Garissa attack.

Yemen

In Yemen, it is believed that over 100,000 people have been displaced by the alleged proxy war between Saudi Arabia and Iran. Houthi rebels have stormed through the country despite Saudi airstrikes’ attempts to stop them. What hasn’t been detailed by the press in the midst of the humanitarian crisis is how it affects women and men differently. Houthi rebels have also put in place a patriarchal system in Yemen and taken away many women’s rights. Furthermore, displaced families and refugees are absolutely gendered in that children are automatically the women’s responsibility due to traditional gender roles. This leaves women with a huge care burden, an extra mouth to feed and a disproportional burden of the humanitarian crisis. For men, given the US support for the Saudi strikes they are probably also implementing the military-aged-male protocol in that when they strike Yemen and kill a man, whether he is in combat or not, of military age (16-60) it is not considered a civilian death. This monstrous foreign policy is sexist and another reason for men to be on board with gender equality.


ISIL’s insurgency spreads: Yarmouk Refugee Camp

ISIL have marched into Yarmouk refugee camp in the suburbs of Damascus, an area ignored by the Asad regime. The conditions in the camp prior to the ISIL occupation were described as abhorrent and inhuman so not that ISIL are occupying the territory things can only get worse. Particularly for women. As aforementioned it goes without saying that women bare the burden in refugee camps and are more likely to be refugees in the first place. In addition, as discussed before, rape and sexual violence are tactics often deployed by ISIL to damage families and cause harm and despite no press reports on this, it seems inevitable that this is happening in Yarmouk.


White South Carolina Policeman Shoots Unarmed Black Man

A video emerged today depicting a white policeman shooting an unarmed black man eight times in his back whilst he fleds. The policeman in question has been sentenced to murder however, this is yet another statistic in a trend of white policemen shooting black men. Black masculinity stereotypes absolutely play a role here, despite never being considered an attributing factor. The hashtag #BlackLivesMatter remains significant in fighting the institutionalised racism in the United States however, an acknowledgement of how black masculinities are constructed and taught to white men plays a crucial yet unacknowledged role here.

Malta Intersexed Babies

In more hopeful yet unappreciated news story this week told of how Malta has been the first state in the world to make the ‘normalisation’ of intersexed babies illegal. It is proven that in many cases intersexed babies are ‘made male’ because it is easier to construct a penis than a vagina or parents may chose male sex because it will benefit their child more. Therefore it can be an immoral and inherently patriarchal practice. However, intersexed politics also have a certain amount of irony to them in that it is often seen abhorrent to attach a babies sex and thus gender to them without their choice and yet that it what we do every single day to babies born with a biological ‘sex.’ Nevertheless, Malta’s decision paves the way for intersexed rights and visibility in the world. After all, around 2% of births are intersexed and this is not a small majority.

Iran beyond the Nuclear Deal: sports events and hijabs

Last week following months of negotiations the US, EU and Iran finally reached an agreement on the future of Iran’s nuclear program. Understandably, this hit the headlines as a success for diplomacy and respect for both sides. I will avoid an angry feminist rant about the patriarchal nature of nuclear arms and majority-male diplomacy. However, what was less reported was the feminist progress that has happened in Iran recently. Firstly, women are now allowed to attend men’s sports events in Iran. Although not the ‘too masculine’ ones such as wrestling (?!) Secondly, women in Iran have been liberating themselves by removing their hijabs, filming it and posting it online. All 3 of these acts demonstrate access to personal freedoms and technology for women in Iran. This is undoubtedly a feminist campaign for Iran’s women! Empowering and inspiring. 

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Mbg3oyeV4Is





Friday, 3 April 2015

UK General Election TV Debates: Why the women won but we're still yet to mention gender, feminism or sexism in national politics.


Last night, in the UK, the leaders of the 7 main parties (Miliband for Labour, Cameron for the Conservatives, Clegg for the Liberal Democrats, Bennett for the Greens, Farage for UKIP, Sturgeon for SNP and Wood for Plaid Cymru) congregated live on national television to win the votes of the British public. This election has already made political history in the UK as we’ve watched the so-called party system be destroyed and replaced with a infiltrations into the mainstream by extreme parties such as UKIP, the Greens and SNP. However, it will also make history as a result of the almost gender balance of candidates: last night 3 of the 7 hopefuls standing behind their podiums were women and this is a success that cannot be understated. Nevertheless, sexism in British politics was proved to be alive and well last night. Not only were the three women candidates and the woman host all consistently and aggressively interrupted by the men throughout the debate but this morning we have all arisen to some outrageous sexism in the pages of our national newspapers. Whilst the Metro reported on Leanne Wood’s ‘sexy’ accent, Sturgeon’s ‘new look’ has been reported on and all the papers commented on the women’s shoes as opposed to their views. The Everyday Sexism project tweeted a ‘bingo card’ of their expectations for the debate and they were not wrong: 


There were four questions asked by the (gender balanced) audience last night. All of them are inherently gendered in both theory and reality and yet there was not a single mention of women or feminism by any of the women or men.

1. The Economy and Austerity 
Whilst Farage made a fool out of himself by continuing his scare-mongering, one-trick-pony rhetoric, the other 3 men stood up to defend austerity. What a surprise the three, white, middle class, able bodied, heterosexual MEN stood up to defend austerity as the solution to economic growth. As I have previously mentioned austerity fundamentally affects women disproportionately to men and this is something that needs to be tackled by any government planning to continue with cuts of public services. Whilst Bennett, Wood and Sturgeon all came out against austerity they did not mention the disproportionate ramifications for women or how they would fight such inequality. While the phrase ‘balance the books’ seemed to be on the lips of particularly Clegg, Cameron and Miliband there was no reference to said books being fundamentally gendered. 

2. The National Health Service
Similarly, none of the leaders mentioned the gendered dynamics of the cuts and ‘tide of privatisation’ forced upon the National Health Service. There are two crucial aspects I’d like to pick up on here: the first was Clegg’s continual reference to mental health as a key Lib Dem manifesto promise. Mental health is an absolutely gendered problem in that it effects men more than women and yet men struggle to reach out for help as a result of the socialised enforcement of stoic masculinity. Secondly, there was continual reference to the segregated nature of health and social care. Health and social care staff is absolutely dominated by women in both the formal and informal sense as a result of the care burden associated with femininity. Nigel Farage’s hideous comments about the burden on the NHS due to immigrants and ‘foreign’ HIV victims had were outrageously racist and had underlying homophobic tones. This only goes to show his desire for the bigotry vote. 

3. Immigration 
Once again here the women served to call out racism, scape goating and fear mongering in the other 4 leaders. Whilst Farage, Milliband, Clegg and Cameron all made vague (or not so vague in Farage’s case) allusions to cutting back on immigration, Wood, Sturgeon and Bennett all made clear assertions of the dangerous discourse surrounding immigration and their desire to subvert said discourse and emphasis the positive contribution of immigration to the UK. 

4. Young People & Students 
Here, there was zero mention of the challenges young women and men face in their daily lives, young people cannot grouped as a collective. What with the rise in tutition fees, young unemployment and the impossibility for young people to buy their own house there is no doubt that young people have heeded the majority of the burden of the austerity package. Labour seem to be after the young persons vote but the lowest voting category is young women and it is extremely significant that our voices are heard as much as our male counterparts. 

What seemed to be the overwhelming outcome from this debate was not who deserved to be the rightful leader of Britain but instead that more women are fundamentally needed in British politics. As an English citizen I cannot vote for either Sturgeon or Wood and yet I was more grateful for their presence than I could ever have predicted. They smashed through the rhetoric that austerity is the only way, they called out racism, sexism and the general lack of compassion in all of the other 5 leaders. As this election continues I wait eagerly for the party who will engage with feminism and combat sexism in Westminster. Labour's pink bus isn't enough for me I'm afraid! For more on this follow the fantastic UK Feminista campaign #VoteFeminist. In the meantime I will continue to deliberate moving to Scotland simply so I can vote for Nicola Sturgeon!

Wednesday, 1 April 2015

The German Wings Catastrophe: Why are we STILL not talking about masculinity and depression induced suicide?

On 24 March a Germanwings plane en route from Barcelona to Dusseldorf carrying 149 passengers and crew crashed in the French Alpes. It has since transpired that one of the co-pilots, Andreas Lubitz, deliberately crashed the plane in an act of murder-suicide. In order to try and explain this tragedy there has been an on-going investigation into the life and mind of Andreas Lubitz to try and understand what would possess someone to kill 150 innocent people and themselves. Whilst much of the French and German press has speculated about the pilot’s history of depression, little of said analysis has pointed towards his gender. What seems evident is that he was diagnosed as depressed and had been deemed unfit to fly by two doctors. Yet even his own girlfriend and parents had very little knowledge of how serious the problem really was. That is not to say that those with mental illnesses cannot hold and thrive in full time employment. Or that depression is necessarily associated with murder suicide. It is extremely significant that media sensationalism and the further stigmatisation of depression and mental illness does not become the legacy of this disaster.

Suicide and as a corollary murder suicide is gendered. Murder suicide figures are much harder to disaggregate and find patterns for as a result of their rarity, particular in this case. However, in the UK 75% of suicides are committed by men. This is a staggering percentage and it can absolutely be attributed to difficultly men face in tackling mental illness. In western society, certain ideals of masculinity are vigorously and subtly enforced upon men from their very first breath and they are extremely damaging. Phrases such as ‘be a man’ and ‘don’t be such a wuss/pussy/girl’ are flung around by parents/family members/friends/teachers/peers/colleagues and the like throughout childhood and into adulthood. Is it any wonder that men struggle to reach out for emotional support or ask for help when struggling with depression? To be a ‘real man’ is the relentless rejection of what it is to be a ‘real woman’ and these damaging gender roles fundamentally exercise themselves in the lived experiences of gendered individuals. Connell (1987) compiled these ideas into an umbrella framework titled ‘hegemonic masculinity’ which literally refers to the most dominant and prized yet coercively consensual way of performing masculinity in a certain time or place. I will post a couple of essays on this subject at the end of this academic year once they have been marked as it is something I have written a lot about in the last year.

Depression and mental health is fundamentally gendered and when it looks to have caused the innocent murder of 150 people, how can we sit back and not address the correlation between (hegemonic) masculinity and suicide? For the families of those innocent lives, this can serve as no justification for such a dreadful act but to see the bigger picture here is to see the inescapable problem of the pressure we place on men to perform their gender in a certain way and how this results in their quashing of emotions. If there was ever a case for men’s ‘embrace of feminism’ and rejection of gender norms (Kimmel, 2011) this is it.

Helpful Sources

Experts Reaction to Mental State of A320 Crash Co-Pilot http://www.sciencemediacentre.org/expert-reaction-to-mental-state-of-a320-crash-co-pilot/ Particularly Ali Haggert’s Comment.


More on Hegemonic Masculinity

Alsop, R., Fitzsimons, A. and Lennon, K. (2002). Theorizing Men and Masculinities. In Alsop, R., Fitzsimons, A. and Lennon, K. (2002). Theorizing Gender. Malden, MA: Blackwell.

Bird, S. (1996). Welcome to the Men’s Club: Homosociality and The Maintenance of Hegemonic Masculinity. Gender & Society 10(2): 120-132.

Carrigan, T., R.W. Connell and J. Lee (1985). Towards a New Sociology of Masculinity. Theory and Society 14(5): 551–604.

Connell, R.W. (1987). Sexual Character. in Gender and power. Stanford, California. Stanford University Press: pp. 167-183.

Connell, R. W. (2005a) Hegemonic Masculinity: Rethinking the Concept. Gender & Society 19(6): 829-859.

Connell, R.W. (2005b) Masculinities. 2nd Edition. Cambridge, United Kingdom. Polity Press.

Demetriou, D. Z. (2001). Connell's Concept of Hegemonic Masculinity: A Critique. Theory and Society 30 (3): 337-361.

Donaldson, Mike. (1993). What is Hegemonic Masculinity? Theory and Society 22(5):643-657.

Goffman, E. (1963). Stigma. Englewood Cliffs, New Jersey: Prentice-Hall.

Hearn, J. (2004). From Hegemonic Masculinity to the Hegemony of Men. Feminist Theory 5 (1): 49-72.

Joe Ehrmann. (2013, February 20) Be A Man: Joe Ehrmann at TEDx Baltimore. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jVI1Xutc_Ws [Accessed: 6 Feb 2015]

Kaufman, M (1994) Men, Feminism and Men’s Contradictory Experiences of Power. In Theorizing Masculinities. Thousand Oaks, California. Sage Publications.

Kaufman, M. and Kimmel, M. (2011). The Guy's Guide to Feminism. Berkeley, California: Seal Press.

Kimmel, M (1994) Masculinity as Homophobia in Brod, H. and Kaufman, M. (1994). Theorizing Masculinities. Thousand Oaks, California. Sage Publications.

The Representation Project (2015) Films: The Mask You Live In. http://therepresentationproject.org/films/the-mask-you-live-in/ Accessed: 10/02/15